| Adam Bernstein | Adam Bernstein | |
| Austin Maguire | Jimmy Paolini | |
| Charnae McCoy | Brendan Grambow | |
Oh DarlingSara Bareilles (The Beatles) · Arr: Dana Lane, Jimmy Paolini | Dana Lane | Dana Lane, Jimmy Paolini | |
| Jamie Tomlinson | Jimmy Paolini | |
AlaskaMaggie Rodgers · Arr: Brian McGrath | Jillian Karande | Brian McGrath | |
| Jimmy Paolini | Jimmy Paolini | |
| Joseph Chong | Brian McGrath | |
| Julianna Choi | Brendan Grambow, Jimmy Paolini | |
| Julia Sokoloff | Jimmy Paolini | |
Wage a WarSonny · Arr: Sydney Hard, Jimmy Paolini, Julius Barriteau | Julius Barriteau | Sydney Hard, Jimmy Paolini, Julius Barriteau | |
GrowFrances · Arr: Sean Naylor | Nancy Rosenberg | Sean Naylor | |
G-TrainThirdstory · Arr: Aaron Weinstein | Ryan Hood | Aaron Weinstein | |
| Eric Chen, Sam Felgoise | Brian McGrath | |
SmokeLuke Levenson · Arr: Brian McGrath | Kerry O'Neil, Brian McGrath | Brian McGrath | |
| — | Jimmy Paolini | |
| Léa Kichler | Nancy Rosenberg | |